I decided to read An Offer From a Gentleman (2001) by Julia Quinn while I waited for the rest of the show to come out. My enthusiasm for the show rolled over into the book, and I enjoyed listening to it. I finished the book before finally watching the last half of the show. Although there were a number of changes made for the adaptation, the basics of the two stories are the same.
Sophie Becket (Baek on the show) is an illegitimate child of the Earl of Penwood and a housemaid. After Sophie's mother died when she was young, she was brought to the Earl's estate. The Earl never paid much attention to her, but he saw that she was well-cared for and educated. When Sophie was still young, the Earl remarried and brought his new wife and two new step-daughters home. The new wife detested that she had to accept and deal with a bastard child from another relationship and treated Sophie horribly. Still things weren't too bad until the Earl unexpectedly died. At that point, the Earl's wife basically turned Sophie into an unpaid, overworked maid.
One day Sophie borrows an old dress and some shoes from Lady Penwood and sneaks into a costume party at Bridgerton House. While there, she meets and enchants/is enchanted by Benedict Bridgerton. However, at midnight, when the masks are supposed to come off, Sophie flees back to Penwood House. The story continues with Benedict trying to find the mystery woman in silver, and Sophie kicked out of Penwood house when Lady Penwood discovers that she had been at the costume party.
Now that I've both read and seen this Bridgerton story, my favorite part is the first half of the television version. The book was fine, but you could tell that it was written a while ago because television Benedict was often more appealing. In the book, Benedict was enraged that Sophie refused to be his mistress. He also told her he would have her put in jail for stealing if she didn't accompany him to London. He threatened her "for her own good" of course, but it made me dislike him. In contrast, the television Benedict was much more understanding.
And I enjoyed the first half because it included the two meeting at the dance, which was very sweet. It also included their time at "My Cottage," which felt something like a fairy tale. The second half of the show had some good parts, but it felt a little more drawn out.
On the whole, this was a fun read and I enjoyed comparing the book to the television show. I generally prefer to read the book before seeing the adaptation, but I don't think it mattered much in this case.






